← Peace between the confederates and James Butler, leads to a split within the confederation
Scottish Presbyterians sell captured Charles I to English parliament →- August 12, 1646
Archbishop Giovanni Battista Rinuccini, an Italian cleric and papal nuncio to the Irish Confederate Catholics during the 1640s, played a significant role in the Irish Confederate Wars. In 1646, he condemned the peace terms agreed upon by the Confederates with James Butler, the 1st Duke of Ormond, who was the Lord Lieutenant of Ireland, representing the English Royalist forces.
Background
Irish Confederate Wars: The Irish Confederate Wars (1641–1653) were a series of conflicts in Ireland that were part of the wider Wars of the Three Kingdoms, which included the English Civil War. The Catholic Confederation of Kilkenny was formed by Irish Catholics in 1642 to defend their religious and political rights against the Protestant English government and to support King Charles I in the hope of securing greater religious freedom.
Rinuccini’s Mission: Giovanni Battista Rinuccini was sent to Ireland by Pope Innocent X in 1645 to provide support to the Irish Catholic cause. His mission was to ensure that any settlement reached in Ireland would fully protect and recognize the Catholic religion. He brought with him funds, arms, and supplies to support the Confederate Catholics in their struggle.
The Ormond Peace
Peace Negotiations: The Irish Confederates, representing various factions with differing interests, entered into negotiations with James Butler, Duke of Ormond. Ormond, a Royalist, sought to secure Irish support for King Charles I in the English Civil War by reaching a peace agreement that would allow Irish Catholics to practice their religion with some concessions but would not fully restore Catholic power or recognize Catholicism as the dominant religion.
The 1646 Peace Treaty: The peace terms, known as the “Ormond Peace,” were signed in 1646. However, the terms were far less favorable to the Catholic cause than many Confederates had hoped. While the treaty offered some religious concessions, it fell short of fully recognizing Catholicism or addressing the broader political and land rights issues that were crucial to many of the Irish leaders.
Rinuccini’s Condemnation
Rinuccini’s Reaction: Archbishop Rinuccini was vehemently opposed to the Ormond Peace, as he believed it betrayed the Catholic cause by failing to secure the full restoration and recognition of Catholicism in Ireland. He viewed the terms as a compromise that favored the English Crown and Protestant interests at the expense of the Catholic population.
Excommunication Threat: Rinuccini took drastic measures to oppose the treaty, including threatening excommunication for any Confederate leaders who supported the peace terms. He believed that true peace could only be achieved with full religious freedom for Catholics and the establishment of a Catholic-controlled government in Ireland.
Divisions Among the Confederates: Rinuccini’s opposition to the treaty deepened divisions within the Confederate leadership. Some factions supported Rinuccini’s hardline stance, while others, more pragmatic, believed that the Ormond Peace was the best deal they could achieve under the circumstances. This internal conflict weakened the Confederation at a critical time.
Aftermath and Impact
Military Conflict Resumes: Rinuccini’s condemnation of the Ormond Peace contributed to the resumption of hostilities. The Confederate Wars continued, leading to further instability and conflict in Ireland. The divisions within the Confederate ranks made it increasingly difficult for them to present a united front against the English Parliamentarians, who were becoming a more formidable force in the ongoing civil wars.
Cromwell’s Invasion: Ultimately, the lack of unity among the Irish Confederates and the failure to secure a strong, cohesive agreement contributed to the downfall of the Confederate cause. In 1649, Oliver Cromwell’s forces invaded Ireland, leading to the brutal suppression of the Irish Catholic population and the conquest of Ireland by the English Parliamentarians.
Legacy: Rinuccini’s role in opposing the Ormond Peace highlighted the complex interplay between religion, politics, and military strategy during the Irish Confederate Wars. His uncompromising stance reflected the deep divisions within Irish society and the challenges of achieving a lasting peace in a time of intense conflict.
Rinuccini’s condemnation of the Ormond Peace remains a significant episode in the history of the Irish Confederate Wars, symbolizing the tensions between religious ideals and political pragmatism in the struggle for Irish independence and Catholic rights.